« BCG's Study of "Innovative Companies" | Main | The Matter with Dell -- According to the Press, the Pundits, and the Professors »

February 17, 2007

Comments

Steve

Hi Phil,

What impresses me with Collin's books is that they seem to be the first that tried to apply any research rigor to begin with. The average business bestseller has all the mystic and validity of the Oracles of Delphi but Collin's at least made the attempt to isolate the variables that drive performance.

What books impress you in the business category? The only other author I can think of is Marcus Buckingham's "First, Break All the Rules."

Phil Rosenzweig

Thanks for the comment, Steve. No question, Jim Collins's books present themselves as serious research, having gathered large amounts of data. But the quality of the data are suspect, and the conclusions are faulty. I'm not sure if you've read my book, but I talk about this at length in Chapters 6 and 7. Collins's claims of scientific rigor are unfounded--and no one has called him on the basic problem, which is the quality of his data.

There are many very good studies that meet the test of rigorous research (as I show in Chapter 8) and these can be found in many serious research journals. But the findings don't make loud claims about achieving great performance, and therefore aren't the stuff of best-sellers. As for good business books, I like several, for which I provide links in the section about further reading. To this list, I would add Clayton Christensen's two excellent books, The Innovator's Dilemma and The Innovator's Solution, plus Michael Porter on Strategy and Jay Galbraith on Organization Design. I also have a soft spot for Larry Bossidy's Execution, which is a bit overblown, but of practical value for managers. Perhaps my favorite that blends an understanding of strategy as decision making under uncertainty, but leadership as the need to inspire with confidence, is Andy Grove's Only the Paranoid Survive.

Steve Barnard

Phil,
I have just finished your book, purchased yesterday after I read the review in USA Today. Previous reading included "Fooled by Randomness", but your book took many of the themes of that book and brought them into a business setting.

Having read "Built to Last", "Good to Great", "In Search of Excellence", etc. I sensed that many of their messages seemed simplistic. Your book has enlightened me. I understand better why I believed that something wasn't quite right about their points. You have made a new fan! I look forward to your next book.

cheap viagra

There has been controversy about the real identity of the architect of the Leaning Tower of Pisa. For many years, the design was attributed to Guglielmo and Bonanno Pisano, a well-known 12th-century resident artist of Pisa, famous for his bronze casting, particularly in the Pisa Duomo.

cheap jordan retro

Even taking a purely traditional approach, mothers need education more than do fathers, because a child's life, his education, begins at his mother's breast.

Free instant poker bonus

I just wanted to say thanks for a wonderful penpal site I havent been here long but Ive already made a couple penpals thanks again. Dave

Free Poker

Here are so many nationalities and concepts that for the people who seek for deep knowledge it's a bless ! Belive me ! Iron Rose

Bonus bez depozytu poker

I love your site! I can't believe you came up with such a great site, I just wanted to let you know that this site has gotten me new friends! Thank you ever so much! Melissa

Poker Money Bonus

Thank you so much for the site! I love this site. It is one of the best sites I have seen for many years. Thank you! I now have 10 penpals that are all from you! Thank you!!!

Bonus Without Deposit

I love this site and I have made alot of freinds here.And I also refered this site to my future sis-in-law she loves it too. Kitlin

Instant Poker Bankrolls

i really enjoy this site i thought i never get much people as pals on this site every since i had place an ad on this site i been getting pals from all over and i want to thank you so much for this site Chad

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Photo